Head-to-Head Dupe Analysis68.3% Match SimilaritySave $42 / Gallon
Benjamin Moore Chelsea Gray
vs Magnolia Home Duke Gray
Looking for a cheap equivalent to Chelsea Gray (HC-168)? Here is the scientific comparison, spectrophotometric ΔE score, and exact formula to get this mixed at Home Depot.
โ๏ธ Side-by-Side Visual Comparison
Notice how the human eye perceives both shades under identical D65 daylight.
ΔE: 7.76
Original (premium)$94/gal
Chelsea Gray
Benjamin Moore (HC-168)
HEX: #85837E โข LRV: 23.3
Budget Dupe (budget)$52/gal
Duke Gray
Magnolia Home (JG-04)
HEX: #8F9696 โข LRV: 31
๐ฏ Editorial Verdict:"Good Coordinating Alternative"
Light Reflectance difference is only 7.7%. Once painted across an entire room, natural light bounce creates identical atmosphere.
Cost Difference
Save $42/gal (45%)
Technical Specification Comparison
Objective measurements recorded under standard CIE D65 illuminant.
| Metric | Benjamin Moore Chelsea Gray | Magnolia Home Duke Gray | Difference / Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hexadecimal Code | #85837E | #8F9696 | ΔE 7.76 |
| sRGB Coordinates | 133, 131, 126 | 143, 150, 150 | Near-parallel chromaticity |
| LRV (Light Reflectance) | 23.3% | 31% | Only 7.7% variance |
| Dominant Undertones | Medium-Dark Charcoal, Warm Brown-Violet, Urban Slate | True Pewter, Cool Concrete, Weathered Stone | Complementary tones |
| Price Per Gallon (MSRP) | $94 | $52 | Save $42/gal |
| Whole House Cost (10 gal) | $940 | $520 | Save $420 Total! |
๐ How to Order this Dupe at Home Depot
Copy and present this exact prompt to the paint counter technician.
"Hi, I would like 1 gallon of Magnolia Home Marquee/Premium tinted to Duke Gray (JG-04). This is a verified match for Benjamin Moore Chelsea Gray (HC-168)."